Monthly Archives: September 2013

PNG mine workers in Australia escape job cuts

ABC Radio Australia

The slowing of Australia’s mining boom has led to big job losses but it seems Papua New Guineans working in Australia are defying the trend and holding on to their jobs.

There are around 3000 skilled Papua New Guineans working in the mining sector in Australia.

Presenter: Jemima Garrett

Speaker: Soleiy Didwick, Vice President, PNG WA; Ben Imbun, School of Management, University of Western Sydney.

In the past 12 months 20,000 jobs have been lost in the Australian mining sector.

Coal has been hardest hit but gold mining and base metals such as copper and nickel are all affected.

The largest community of Papua New Guinea mine workers is in Western Australia.

Soleiy Didwick, Vice President of the the community organisation PNG WA, is a fly-in fly-out auto-electrician who works at BHP Billiton’s Mt Newman mine.

He says Papua New Guineans are not losing their jobs.

DIDIWICK: I can’t really see anything happening to papua New Guineans. Most of us are still in our permanent roles.

GARRETT: Why is it, do you think, that papua New Guineans arn’t losing their jobs when other people are?

DIDIWICK: One of the things that I can see, as a Papua New Guinean, I think the culture that we come from, we don’t seems to jump jobs every now and then and this probably builds trust within the employer.

GARRETT: The Papua New Guineans working in Australia are the cream of the PNG workforce, often with many years of experience in tough environments.

Ben Imbun, from the School of Management at the University of Western Sydney says the seniority of the roles they hold helps protect them from being sacked.

IMBUN: Senior mines project engineer, senior open pit mining engineer, drill blasts you know, engineers and all that, so it is quite key jobs in supervisory some of them.

GARRETT: Before the boom started to tighten you found Papua New Guineans were getting promoted faster than their Australian counterparts is that still the case?

IMBUN: Still, stil the case because of the experience, their performance. In fact as I’ve heard, some of the PNGers in particular that I’ve interviewed, they said they were doing a lot of training of Australian young miners, engineers and other technical, chemists, yeah!

GARRETT: Papua New Guineans are not immune from the job cuts.

Some have moved from Western Australia to the Northern Territory to follow the work.

Despite a skills shortage at home Soliey Didwick says none are looking to return to PNG.

DIDIWICK: When we go back there, we will be underpaid like 3 times 4 times less than what we get it, here. They are not looking to go back to PNG most of them are talking to go overseas.

GARRETT: So if they lose their job they will go on to another country overseas.

DIDWICK: That is correct.

GARRETT: Some Papua New Guinean mine workers have moved on to Asia or Africa, or joined others already working in the Middle East.

Ben Imbun says the brain drain from PNG is not just affecting mining professionals.

IMBUN: Also the pilots as well. You wouldn’t believe it. PNG is one of the toughest flying conditions in the world. So what had happened, Air Niugini the national airline up there it is a parallel story so I am just touching on that. Some of these local pilots are flying Abu Dhabi, Etihad airlines, even one if the flight controller, controls the whole operations, previously they flew for Air Niugini, local pilots. They have also come out, they have gone similar to the extractive industry workers. So some are flying for Cathay Pacific and so forth.


1 Comment

Filed under Australia, Papua New Guinea

Artisanal miners an ongoing problem at Solomons gold mine

Radio New Zealand

Allegations of the use of mercury are among ongoing issues at the Gold Ridge mine in Solomon Islands.

It is four years since the country’s sole mine was reopened – a decade on from the ethnic tensions that forced its closure.

Both the mining company and the government are being urged to attend to a range of problems – from reports of river pollution to what are thought to be growing numbers of illegal miners and traders.

Annell Husband reports:

Gold Ridge is thought to contribute about 20% of the country’s gross domestic product. St Barbara Limited took ownership of the mine just under a year ago and according to the company’s website is the sixth owner since open pit mining began in 1998. The managing director and chief executive says the company is very concerned about illegal miners – not because of the gold they’re taking but because of the risks to their safety. Tim Lehany says up to 200 illegal miners – including children – go into the pits every night and the site’s terrain and issues of customary land ownership make it difficult to stop them. He says it’s not the job of the mining company’s security team to get into physical confrontations.

“TIM LEHANY: We believe that is the role of the Royal Solomons Police. These people are all armed with bush knives, we’ve had threats made, we’ve had stones thrown and particularly people who’re intoxicated can get pretty excited and that just adds another dimension to this whole thing.”

Tim Lehany says Gold Ridge Mine Mining Limited, is working closely with the police. He says he wants to see more people being arrested and charged.

“TIM LEHANY: It’s a complex problem. There are lots of aspects to this illegal mining activity and I think it needs to be tackled on a number of fronts. So first of all, I think people need to be arrested and charged with trespass and then of course you can also work on the side where the gold is actually going and where the money changes hands.”

Tim Lehany says arrests at the international airport near Honiara of foreign nationals is proof that the government is trying to do something about the trade in illegal gold. He denies the involvement of Solomon Islands politicians in the trade – but Transparency Solomon Island’s chairperson Ruth Liloqula says their involvement is a known fact. She says a government minister is a licensed dealer and all sorts of other unlikely people – including nurses and students – are being used as front people for those buying the illegally-mined gold at discounted prices.

“RUTH LILOQULA: Unless the government acts there is no way the only mining company we have in the country is going to solve the problem of illegal miners. Because the people that have been licensed to deal in gold are the ones that are encouraging this practice.”

But Ruth Liloqula says Transparency Solomon Islands’ biggest concern is the possibility of mercury contamination at the mine. She says Transparency understands some of the operators are either using or going to get local miners to use mercury for extraction.

“RUTH LILOQULA: The possibility of what is happening in Ghana with the use of mercury and no attention is paid to environmental damage and river system pollution… So we need the government to follow the law – the law is pretty good. But at the moment we are not following it.”

St Barbara’s Tim Lehany says the mining company doesn’t use mercury but he’s also heard the rumours of its use and says if they’re true, that’s a very serious issue. Earlier this year Solomon Islands’ parliament heard that villagers along the Metapona River could no longer use the water for drinking, bathing, washing their clothes or fishing – nor could they grow crops along the riverbanks. But Mr Lehany says if that is the case it’s nothing to do with Gold Ridge.

“TIM LEHANY: We’re not contributing to any poisoning, in inverted commas, of the river. As I’ve said, we have an extensive sampling programme, we can demonstrate that we have not contributed to the condition of the river. Greater concern to us are the sanitary conditions in the villages downstream that pollute the river”

Tim Lehany accepts that human effluent is unlikely to affect crops but they could stop growing for a variety of reasons. But the MP who represents the communities who live downstream of the mine’s tailing dam says they have additional concerns. Martin Sopage says more than five thousand people would be affected by a dam failure and they want the mining company to discharge some of the water.

“MARTIN SOPAGE: The dam is continuing to rise and the construction is continuing to build up and the water is continuing to build up so we can’t think this is safe for us at the downstream. So there’s a very risk for us in the community there.”

But Tim Lehany says lifting the tailings dam is no cause for concern.

“TIM LEHANY: What I can say is that we put a lot of work into diverting run off away from the dam. So we manage the dam by making sure that as little water as possible from rainfall runs into it. In periods of extreme rainfall the dam level rises. We pump as much as we can back to the plant and that’s the way we manage it.”

But Tim Lehany says the company has a licence to discharge water from that treatment plant, which it uses to clear the water of cyanide, arsenic and other toxins used in the mining process. He says the company has done everything that is reasonably required of it and has been in continual discussions with the environment department.

1 Comment

Filed under Environmental impact, Solomon Islands

PNGSDP faces probe

Post Courier

TWO major investigations will be carried out by the National Government relating to the exit of BHP and the establishment of PNG Sustainable Development Program Limited.

The Taskforce Sweep will also be asked to investigate huge spending by the management and board of PNGSDPL, including hiring of consultants, where it is alleged that millions of kina have been used for projects which have failed to materialise.

Prime Minister Peter O’Neill announced yesterday that the first investigation will review the manner in which BHP was given an unconditional indemnity as part of its exiting Ok Tedi Mining Limited, and the second into major spending by the PNG Sustainable Development Program since its establishment.

Mr O’Neill said the review into the circumstances surrounding the granting of the unconditional indemnity to BHP for environmental and social damage by the then Government, in which Sir Mekere Morauta was Prime Minister.

“The Government needs to ascertain whether any breaches of the Constitution, or the laws of Papua New Guinea was involved in the agreement, which was personally negotiated by the then Prime Minister,” he said.

“We will make the report public, and then take advice from the government’s lawyers on whether further action is justified. The fact that Sir Mekere was appointed chairman of PNGDSP, and then OTML, within a short period of his departure from the national Parliament raises serious questions in the minds of many people, given the influence BHP continued to exercise after it allegedly ended its involvement in OTML.

“We need to know exactly how the process was developed and implemented by the Morauta Government.”

Mr O’Neill said many MPs and concerned citizens and business people from the Western Province and elsewhere had raised with him serious concerns about the spending by the PNGSDP on major projects that had either lost money or never eventuated.

The national Government will appoint an independent, highly regarded accountancy firm to conduct an audit of spending on major projects by the PNGSDP since its establishment.

“Two projects that clearly must be independently assessed are the millions of kina lost on the Cloudy Bay timber project, and the expenditure of perhaps more than K100 million on feasibility studies on the Daru port project.

“There are claims that money has just been wasted, and the project is as far away from being developed as ever,” he said.

Mr O’Neill said the national Government would make public the report of the independent audit, and implement any recommendations it made.

“I am sure the independent auditors will look into the approval processes for the spending, and why so much money belonging to the people of the Western Province has been wasted,” he said.

Mr O’Neill said he hoped the chairman, board and management of the PNGSDP would co-operate fully with the independent auditor.

“This is about transparency and accountability-and it must also be about not making the same serious errors in spending on major projects again,” Mr O’Neill said.

In the meantime, the Government will ask the Taskforce Sweep team to investigate huge spending by the management and board of PNGSDPL, including hiring of consultants, where millions of kina have been used for projects which have failed to materialise.

“These are monies belonging to the people of Western Province. They have the right to know their funds have been managed, by those trusted to do so. Those responsible must face the law like everyone?” PM O’Neill said.


Filed under Environmental impact, Financial returns, Papua New Guinea

Porgera MOA review completed

Post Courier

THE third review on the Memorandum of Agreement for the Porgera project that was signed 24 years ago was completed in Kokopo, East New Britain last week with a revised version by the end of the week.

In 1989, under a tripartite arrangement, the Porgera MoA was signed between the national and provincial governments, and landowners.

Contained in the agreement were benefit sharing arrangements and projects to be undertaken by various parties mineral royalty payments, special support grant, tax credit scheme, equity, Porgera Long Term Sustainable Development Plan, law and order, environment protection, preference in supply and procurement, local business development, training and employment, and Porgera township development among other issues.

Following the outcome of this review, some new clauses were added into the MoA to include issues like resettlement, review timeframe, law and order, and women in mining.

These were not in the existing MoA and will be included in the revised version.

During the review, Barrick was invited to be a party to the MoA but declined saying it was happy to participate in development arrangements with the MOA parties as the project developer.

It also made a commitment to honor projects and developments that would require its input during the meeting.

According to Dr Ila Temu, the company has many other agreements in place in for many of the issues similar to the ones contained in the MoA that are current and are yet to be fulfilled.

“Any commitment in the MoA for Barrick to come in, we will take in.

“We don’t need an MoA to fulfill our commitments,” he said

The review was concluded last Saturday, with all parties agreeing for the revised MOA draft to be finalised and submitted to cabinet for approval.


Filed under Financial returns, Papua New Guinea

‘Criminal Terrorist’, ‘Fanatic’ and ‘Mentally Sick’ – BCL’s Largest Shareholder Sprays Bougainvillean Leaders

Winners are grinners, Bougainville Copper Limited (BCL) Chairman, Peter Taylor, and the largest individual BCL shareholder, Axel Sturm, recently met at the opulent Goodwood Park Hotel in Singapore to discuss Bougainville’s future.

Axel G. Sturm and Peter R. Taylor having lunch in Singapore.

Axel G. Sturm and Peter R. Taylor having lunch in Singapore.

In recent years Sturm has become a frequent commentator on Bougainville affairs. His knack for insulting sound bites has made him a favourite among journalists. Many of Sturm’s most legendary sprays are launched via the European Shareholders of Bougainville (ESBC) website which he administers. There he has slammed Bougainvillean leaders, writers and filmmakers accusing them of being ‘criminal terrorists’, ‘fanatics’ and ‘mentally sick’. Sturm has also attacked PNG statesmen and decorated foreign commentators who he accuses of being ‘naïve’, ‘delirious’ and dishonest.

Yet far from distancing themselves from Sturm’s inflammatory remarks, BCL it would seem endorses them. In an address published on Sturm’s ESBC website, Peter Taylor writes:

“As chairman of Bougainville Copper I am restricted in what I can say due to corporations’ laws. You do not have the same restrictions. Your analysis of the situation on Bougainville is appreciated” (ESBC Website, May 2011).

Here is a selection of Sturm’s “appreciated” analysis, which BCL’s Chairman travels several thousand miles to hear:

On Remembering the Bougainville Conflict

Bougainville writer Leonard Fong Roka has written numerous touching stories on the Bougainville war including one about his father’s tragic murder. This is the advice given to Roka by Sturm:

“Dear Leonard, the Bougainville Crisis was a nasty experience – for sure! But I believe that the Second World War was even worse for Bougainvilleans. Certainly one must not forget what happened and one has to learn from mistakes. But touching old wounds regularly is not helpful at all for healing” (PNG Attitude, 3/11/2012).

On BCL Liability for War Crimes and Environmental Damage

Sturm has denied BCL’s liability:

“We shareholders – as I understand, Rio Tinto, also, is a major shareholder – we are OK to invest another US$5 billion into the mine [on which they will make a large profit – PNG Mine Watch]. And I think that is more than enough compensation for a situation that was not caused by Bougainville Copper” (Radio New Zealand, 16/7/13).

He has also seems to suggest BCL was the victim:

“The mine was closed nearly 20 years ago mainly due to the secessionist conflict in which BCL was made responsible. Therefore, we believe that it would be a friendly sign of the Bougainvillean landowners to invite BCL to come back to work on the island” (Post Courier 8/5/2008).

On the Grand Chief, Sir Michael Somare

“I consider him as a poor, delirious old man who is more and more out of his mind” (ESBC Press Release, 26/6/2011).

On Critics of Rio Tinto

Sam Kauona – Former Commander of the Bougainville Revolutionary Army

“Sam Kauona is one of the alleged murderers of the so called Bougainville Revolutionary Army (BRA)! He is on the pay-roll of foreign notorious backdoor players! Most of his life he spent as a hardened criminal terrorist by intimidating, robbing and also presumably killing innocent Bougainvillean citizens” (ESBC Website, 27/2/2013).

Clive Porabou – Bougainvillean Environmentalist and filmmaker

Sturm accuses Porabou of being a “fanatic”. He claims: “Clive Porabou – mislead and remote-controlled by anarchic left-wing ecologist groups in London (UK) and Australia – still continues spreading lies and jealousy in the internet and on the ground” (ESBC Press Release, 5/4/2011).

In a further exchange Sturm accused Porabou of being mentally ill:

“Parabou: In this regard, the closing down of Panguna Mine involved blood and the loss of lives of twenty thousand fighters, innocent children, men and women from the Southern tip to the Northern isles of Mekamui/Bougainville.

Sturm:   You know very well that only approximately 1200 people were killed by unrest on Bougainville. The others died because of lack of medicines and normal death in that period. … Stop to publish all that bullshit now or are you mentally sick??” (see ESBC Website, 20/10/2011)

Lawrence Daveona – Chairman of the Panguna Mine Affected Landowners Association

Sturm on Daveona in 2008: “When I met him in May in Port Moresby, I had been deeply impressed by Lawrence Daveona. He is the ideal mediator in this sensitive issue. He has our confidence and our full support as well. Earlier than others Lawrence understood that the only way of bringing enduring peace and prosperity to the island of Bougainville means first of all getting all parties concerned together” (ESBC Website, 7/7/2008).

Sturm on Daveona in 2013: “It is true that for many years the ESBC supported Mr. Daveona’s efforts to resume mining by BCL. Unfortunately I had to stop funding Mr. Daveona because of his increasing inappropriate behaviour towards Bougainville’s President, Dr. John Momis and myself. Sadly there was no more sustainable cooperation possible for the benefit of Bougainvilleans. Today, quite obviously, Mr. Daveona follows his very own agenda and private interest which is proved by his recent statements. He does not have any regard for the people of Bougainville or even the Panguna landowner’s future” (Mine Watch PNG, 29/6/2013).

Dr Kristian Lasslett – Lecturer in Criminology, University of Ulster

Dr Lasslett’s research uncovered evidence confirming Rio Tinto’s infamous role in the Bougainville conflict. Sturm claimed: “It’s really shameful if an expert in criminology completely ignores facts and reality. Your naive adoption of statements and claims from rebel groups on the ground disqualify you as an honest scientist [Dr Lasslett’s claims are based on statements made by BCL Managers and internal BCL records – PNG Mine Watch] …I suppose your work in Ulster [Northern Ireland], a region well known for rebellion and organised crime, troubled your vision…Unfortunately you are also allowed to spread your ideas among you students. You shall not use your academic position as a platform for indoctrination and agitation” (PNG Attitude, 26/4/2012).

Brian Thomson – Journalist, SBS Australia

Thomson produced a powerful piece on Bougainville’s tragic past, including material on Rio Tinto’s role in the hostilities. Sturm responded: “Thomson’s loud presentation dismantles him as a naive and unprofessional 3rd class journalist” (ESBC Website, 26/6/2011). Thomson has won two Walkley Awards and a UN Peace Prize.

On Bougainville’s Future and Mining

In an interview with the Post Courier Sturm suggests Bougainville could become the next United Arab Emirates or even the Cayman Islands, a notorious tax haven:

“He [Sturm] also said that if the treasure in Bougainville was exploited, Bougainville would become one of the most fascinating places in the Pacific region [its not already ?– PNG Mine Watch]. Mr Sturm said Bougainville could be compared to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) where it was just an ordinary country before oil was found but today was the most prosperous nation in the world. He said if Bougainville considered venturing into mining activities, revenue earned from this industry would be used to fund other sectors such as tourism which would also benefit the whole region. Mr Sturm said the UAE was the wealthiest region and the money gave the Arabs the liberty to cultivate their ancient traditions [note tradition is alive and well on Bougainville – PNG Mine Watch]. Also, in far future Bougainville might become a fiscal paradise like Cayman Islands, Bahamas or other situated next door to the emerging markets of Asia, he said”. (Post Courier, 6/5/2006)


Filed under Financial returns, Papua New Guinea

Bringing Mr Pip to life

Kate Mead | Fairfax

INSPIRED: Xzannjah, who plays Matilda, and Hugh Laurie as Mr Watts.

INSPIRED: Xzannjah, who plays Matilda, and Hugh Laurie as Mr Watts.

Rawiri Paratene spent his first night in Papua New Guinea in police headquarters with Andrew Adamson. The pair were not there as law breakers, mind, but for the rather frightening reason that the 2011 Japanese tsunami had just struck and the Pacific island was vulnerable.

Paratene and Adamson were safer in this police house, located high on a hill, than if they had stayed in their previous dwelling. “If the tsunami went wider we were going to be the first hit, so it was an amazing time,” says Paratene. “My first night on the job with Andrew Adamson was spent with us sleeping on the floor in police digs hoping that a tsunami wouldn’t wipe the islands out.”

Fortunately Papua New Guinea remained safe and Paratene could continue working there as acting coach for the film Mr Pip, directed by Adamson.

The film was largely shot on Bougainville and Paratene, who spent a total of four months on the island, worked with many locals – untrained actors who had roles as villagers – and lead actress, newcomer Xzannjah. In fact, the only person on Bougainville to appear on screen that Paratene didn’t coach was the experienced Hugh Laurie.

Now 17, Xzannjah was just 14 when she began working on Mr Pip. While living on Bougainville, Paratene stayed with Xzannjah and her family in their home in Arawa, and he says he felt like part of the family. He can’t speak more highly of the young actress. “Xzannjah is bright, the camera adores her. She works really hard – we would be doing a full day’s work and then she would be filming all day and she would come home from filming and do study,” he says. “She must have got tired but she never showed it . . . as a 14-year-old girl would be entitled to.”

For the unacquainted, Mr Pip tells the story of a young girl, Matilda (Xzannjah) stuck in the ruinous clutches of war on Bougainville, all the while being inspired by her teacher, Mr Watts (Laurie), who reads Great Expectations to his class. Published in 2006, the critically-acclaimed novel earned its author, Lloyd Jones, a place on the shortlist of the Man Booker Prize. The film adaptation is a magnificent work, cinematically beautiful, and with marvellous acting. It is, in turn, funny and harrowing. The depiction of conflict during the civil war, which lasted from 1988 to 1998, is raw and affecting.

“In Arawa you can still see the scars of war are still there and it still hasn’t recovered,” says Paratene. “I loved that [the people] made a stand. It was costly but I love that they stood up to the giant money powers that be and said ‘we don’t want to play your game anymore’, and as far as I can see they won. They’re very admirable people but there’s a lot of hurt still there.”

Xzannjah believes the film, and indeed the book itself, fulfils an important function of bringing Bougainville’s dark history to people’s attention. “I thought it was a very, very good story. I mean, the story itself helps people to realise the humanitarian version of conflict that took place in Bougainville, because most of the time [when] you hear about the conflict that took place, people just see the political part of it, like ‘oh, there was a war about the mine’ but they don’t actually see all the pain and suffering that people had to go through, that people had to experience, and how it scarred them for life, and how people had to find it within themselves to actually move on from the experience.”

Paratene agrees the story is powerful: “I read the script before I read the novel, and the way that Andrew had written the script, he clearly wanted to make a film that ‘went there’ – went into the hideous, ugly, unnecessariness of war, and this spoke to me loud and clear.”

Xzannjah, who admits she is quite shy, is still getting used to all the attention brought about by the film. “I don’t put myself in the spotlight. People don’t take notice of me, so it’s all been very different and very new.”

She mostly grew up in Bougainville but moved around the place according to the work her mother, Healesville Joel, got in her profession as a gynaecologist. Last month, Xzannjah moved to

Gladstone, near Brisbane, after her mother got a job there.

Joel also plays Matilda’s mother in Mr Pip, a role that unveiled a new dynamic between the two. “They actually had to teach me how to talk back and shout at my mum,” Xzannjah laughs. “When I play Matilda onscreen, people get to see a side of me that they don’t usually see. I get to get angry, I get to be disobedient.”

In reality Xzannjah is very humble and has a warm disposition, and this newfound fame seems surprising to her. “Back in my normal life I don’t make such a huge deal of it. But the thing is I’m walking down the street and then someone says ‘Hey, you were great!’ and they come and shake my hand and say ‘thanks a lot,’ and I say, ‘For what!? Do I know you?’, ‘oh, no, I just watched your trailer’, ‘oh, thank you’.”

She prefers to take in the world around her, rather than be the focus of it. “I like thinking – I don’t know how to put it, but I find people – how they live their lives – quite fascinating. I like to sit down and watch how they live their lives and think about it then I write down stuff, just take notes and ideas, and write down short stories.”

Acting has been a passion of Xzannjah’s since she was in primary school and performed in musicals including Bedside Manner, Ratbags, A Christmas Carol, and she played the role of Jesus in The Passion of the Christ. But Xzannjah had to put her stage talents on hold after her mother wanted her to concentrate more on school. “Back home I was like, oh I have a dream to act but here [Papua New Guinea] actors only get so far – I didn’t imagine this. And then when [Mr Pip] came up I was like, ah OK, why don’t I just try, and then here I am!”

Xzannjah originally wanted to become a petroleum engineer, and she’s still planning on attending university and studying science to perhaps follow through with this career. Though it’s clear film is where her heart is. “A dream of mine is to become like Andrew: write the screenplay and direct the movie, and become a producer also,” she says. “If there’s a future for me in the film industry, I would definitely like to carry on. I’m loving it.”

1 Comment

Filed under Environmental impact, Human rights, Papua New Guinea

The Insatiable Nautilus

Moyai Saweri | Papua New Guinea My Country

Loosed upon the Earth I pride
Revelations pale horse I ride
Speaking great against the mighty cape
The Bismark shall be mine to rape
I’ll lather in the spoils of war
The dogs set loose upon the floor
But too late, too late, I’ll have my fill
And Bismark shall be mine until
My avarice shall know no end
I’ll pillage all I want and then
The salty blanket in my grasp
Shall silted waters stroke and clasp
But too late, too late, I’ll have my fill
And Bismark shall be mine until
My marauding gape shall suffer none
Somare’s face shall be my gun
A fist-full here a fist-full there
I’ll rip of PNG’s underwear
Eyes wet with tortured pleas
Shall not waver my victored knees
It’s my threshold to force aside
Your pitiful screams woe betide
But too late, too late, I’ve had my fill
And Bismark shall be silent, still…


Filed under Environmental impact, Papua New Guinea

Goroka pipal ino laikim mining

Caroline Tiriman

Ol pipal blong Eastern Highlands provins blong Papua New Guinea i laik tokim gavman long noken tingting long kirapim ol wok mining long ples blong ol.

Odio: Kenn Mondiai,Executive director blong “Partners with Melanesians”, long PNG itoktok wantem Caroline Tiriman

Ol pipal blong ol laen wan pisin blong Ona Keto, Watabung, Komungu, Yamofe na Komingareka i bin autim despla toktok ino long taem igo pinis bihaen long wanpla laen Mining Warden blong  Mineral Resources Authority (MRA) ibin laik go toktok wantem ol long mekim sampla wok painimaut long graon blong ol.

Ol despla laen wan pisin itok oli no laikim wok mining long wonem oli laikim envairaman blong ol istap gut na emi no ken bagarap long ol pipia blong wok mining.

Kenn Mondiai, chif executive blong Partners with Melanesians i kam long Watabung na emi tok ol pipal blong ino laikim tru ol wok mining long graon blong ol long wonem oli laikim ples blong ol istap olsem bifo bifo iet ikam inap nau.

Mr Mondiai itok ol pipal i lukim pinis planti bagarap em ol wok mining isave kamapim long ol narapla ples long kantri na oli no laik bungim ol despla heve tu.

1 Comment

Filed under Environmental impact, Papua New Guinea

ANU’s Howes far from an independent voice in OK Tedi debate

As tensions over Ok Tedi and its acquisition by the O’Neill government reached boiling point recently, the Australian and PNG media went in search of an ‘independent’ expert to evaluate the impact of this political move. Supposedly they found one, Prof Stephen Howes, Director of the Development Policy Centre, a think tank attached to the Australian  National University.

Interviewed on ABC he warned that the move to ‘nationalise’ Ok Tedi will deter foreign investors from taking the plunge into PNG, crippling its economy. The Post-Courier gave Howes an entire page to express his views on this political episode.

But little attention has been devoted to contextualising his commentary. The majority of Howes’ professional life has been spent in the World Bank and AusAID, two institutions intimately involved in commodifying PNG’s land and mineral resources so they can be sold off to foreign investors – evidently this will help PNG’s development. It has worked ‘wonderfully’ to date.

Howes joined the World Bank in 1994 and spent ten years at the institution before taking up a post at AusAID in 2005. Howes remained at AusAID, where he was Chief Economist, until 2007. Then he embarked on an academic career, setting up the Development Policy Centre (DPC) in September 2010.

And who should be the main funder of this policy centre? Why Howes’ former employer AusAID. According to the Centre’s 2012 Annual Report: “Our 2012 income was $481,364 [approximately 1.3 million kina]. Our largest source of funding was for the PNG Promoting Effective Public Expenditure (PEPE) project, which is funded by AusAID through its Economic and Public Sector Program”.

Of course it is fairly common these days to see aid money earmarked for foreign countries flooding Australia’s academic institutions. However, it is ironic that the DPC provides no financial statements in their Annual Report. As a result the Australian and PNG public are unable to scrutinize how the aid funding is being spent by the DPC – they are not exactly setting the standard then on ‘promoting effective public expenditure’.

Before the media begins parading certain opinions as impartial, they might want to give their audience the low down on the speaker’s institutional past, former World Bank and AusAID loyalists are not exactly independent authorities.


Filed under Environmental impact, Financial returns, Papua New Guinea

Row over PNG’s Ok Tedi nationalisation hots up

Rowan Callick | The Australian 

THE row over the Papua New Guinea government’s nationalisation of the country’s biggest single taxpayer, the Ok Tedi copper and goldmine, is heating up, but ratings agency Standard and Poor’s believes the impact may be quarantined if the move is “an isolated case”.

The government named the first four members of its new board without any independent directors, although further appointments are expected.

No details have been given about whether, or how much, compensation will be paid for the cancellation — through legislation — of the 63 per cent of Ok Tedi Mining shares that had been owned by the PNG Sustainable Development Program trust.

The new board members are the acting heads of the PNG Treasury and of the Western provincial government where the mine is based, and Ok Tedi’s managing director Nigel Parker.

The fourth and most controversial member is Jacob Weiss — an Israeli economist, long-time PNG central bank adviser, and the representative of Prime Minister Peter O’Neill in failed negotiations with SDP.

Dr Weiss was formerly a board member of the trust, until suddenly switching sides.

The new board is expected to answer directly to Mr O’Neill.

Craig Michaels, Melbourne-based associate director of sovereign ratings at Standard and Poor’s, yesterday told The Australian that the business community would be watching the impact of the Ok Tedi move closely.

He said “the legislated removal of immunity of BHP-Billiton” — which handed control of Ok Tedi to SDP as it quit, 10 years ago, from compensation claims — “will have been particularly surprising”.

The government was highly reliant on the resources sector, he said, so any damage to the sector “would have a big impact on the economy and on government revenues”.

The establishment by ExxonMobil of a liquefied natural gas project there, he said, “suggests if the returns are high enough, foreign investors are willing to work and invest there”.

Stephen Howes, director of the Development Policy Centre at the Australian National University, said of the nationalisation that “while the government has achieved a stunning victory, it is quite possibly a temporary one” — with legal challenges expected in Port Moresby and in Singapore, where SDP is domiciled, although all its management and staff are in PNG.

The Catholic Bishops of PNG have issued a statement that SDP “has supported hundreds of projects nationwide with integrity”.

“In contrast, government, by itself, often struggles to successfully carry out community-based . . . or even larger development projects. Politics plays a large part in this, and corruption is a truly serious problem.”

1 Comment

Filed under Environmental impact, Financial returns, Papua New Guinea