A rather interesting debate erupted on the social network Facebook, after my story titled ‘Ramu Nico’s extreme promotion of Chromite lies’ got published on the PNG MineWatch blog and the link got spread around.
Below is a good example of what happened to someone’s wall when the link to this story was posted. It picked up a debate, interestingly with MCC’s Jennifer Gaori (aka Zenna Gaori on facebook), who wasted no time to defend the Chinese over her own country men and women’s lives as stated by one of the others who commented.
Jennifer, did a very bad job when she ‘confidently’ told the person who posted the link to not depend on Google to know how poisonous the Chromite Class 6 POISON is, but rather to trust the information the Chinese have her put together in an attempt to lie to the people of Basamuk, Kumbrukari and Madang as a whole.
Off course we all know how stupid that is but poor Jennifer/Zenna (at her-that level) doesn’t realize she has been and is being used along with many other Papua New Guineans like Lima Mullung, the Basamuk Landowner Association’s chairman.
Below is the exchange, for now we’ll call the person who posted ‘PWP’, as in the ‘Person Who Posted’ because our focus is more on Jennifer aka Zenna-Environment Officer/Health Safety and Environment Management Department/Ramu NiCo Management (MCC) Limited.
Posted November 20 at 1:54pm · chromium 6 – this shit is soo bad it killed thousands of people in chromite mines in countries like india & africa. It is a proven carcinogen for cancer and MCC is going to mine it here in PNG and they paid ‘Wantok Niuspepa’ to print all this rubbish bout it being safe! Wheres frigin DEC? Can some authorized png govt dept responsible take some proactive measures to investigate this?? Cancer is rising in PNG and here we are literally asking for more! dang.
- Zenna Gaori people need more awareness into this. NGOs have to get their facts right before airing out. @environmentdeskrnml November 20 at 3:30pm
PWP Google it up. don’t hurry up to diss NGO’s who actually do their background research. ud be surprised and I presume you’ve read ur employers EIA on chromite mining & handling? states a’ possible leakage of chromium 6′. shudnt we be worried? November 20 at 3:49pm
- Zenna Gaori you and your NGO need an awareness on this topic. BRG was chased off at Basamuk by landowners a few months back regarding the very topic. you only do your desktop google and think you have facts but you don’t. please feel free to come by at our office November 20 at 4:31pm
PWP hey now,i wud come by your office if I was in madang. trust me. but I did read the EIA report of chromite mining and handling (done by MCC consultants) and they admitted a leakage of this deadly stuff. cud u gurantee the people of Madang its safety? why is MCC going to all the trouble to ship chromite if there isn’t going to be any danger? people will be wearing face mask, escorted by guard dog security, only travel at night time during the transportation of chromite? aren’t those precautions abit too dramatic if u say its safe? oh and btw, those LO’s who chased BRG away as u say are prolly ones fighting to get a chunk from the ‘benefits’ from the chromite and nothing to do with BRG and what it stands for.
- Zenna Gaori i have alot to tell you about chromite. i can email you an awareness doc if you want this is so as to make you understand more. alot of awareness has already been conducted in madang n media, if only you attended then you wont be posting this November 20 at 10:32pm ·
PWP plis email me by all means.. M really interested. i see u still havent answered my question bout how safe you think it is to what ur EIA report states. November 20 at 11:16pm
PWP Looking forward to it.November 21 at 6:49am
PWP hehehehe…sure. its your bread & butter. November 21 at 11:15am
- Zenna Gaori ofcourse November 21 at 12:04pm
- Zenna Gaori i wrote a brief during lunch hour as part of awareness. check your email November 21 at 2:50pm
ALERT! She ‘WROTE’ IT HERSELF during lunch hour!
- Zenna Gaori it may sound too good to be true, well afterall its the company’s obligation as a developer to impacted landowners. November 21 at 4:37pm
- Trangu Man Zenna Gaori……I’m sorry to say that you’re NOT smart at all! The least you can do is defend the Chinese over your own country men, but you did! SHAME! You boast about being in that small confined office ‘belonging to those Chinese’. Google is where everybody is and not just the Chinese to push their propaganda using puppets on strings…I mean people like you. Chromite Definition on Google is more reliable than chromite information in your, actually their office because after all, its all LIES again put together to fool people, and you obviously. What saddens me is that you believe and don’t realize you’re one of the FOOLS being USED, and is standing up for them (the very panic stricken Chinese) because of that lousy package you get and nothing more, maybe more ( …. … … …… ) only you know. One day you’ll realize they’ve taken all and packed up and last, and you? Left behind obviously, and you won’t even be on their minds, even right from this second…unless….well then only you would know. You are not smart at all. You are one of the FOOLS, maybe bigger because of your plain ignorance November 22 at 4:27pm
- Zenna Gaori trangu man, you sound emotional and narrow minded. i am not at your level and am not putting myself in that position. so say all you want. November 22 at 5:08pm
- Trangu Man Zenna Gaori, yes you are not at my level i know you are so low and so so so cheap as those cheap chinese at mcc and so desperate like them to see development, YOU SOUNDED EMMOTIONAL AND IN FACT YOU WERE UPSET AT THE FIRST PLACE THATS WHY YOU COMMENTED…November 23 at 1:37pm
- Zenna Gaori trangu man, don’t want to communicate with idiots like you. you don’t know anything about mining or ramu nico, you only heard rumors about the company and think all you know are truths, you heard lies so keep your comments to yourself November 23 at 3:48pm
- Ted Soaremai Ha.ha.ha.ha, sorry couldn’t help stopping over. Zenna Gaori, was going to address you as Mrs but. What lies are you referring to haha? Everything is with hard evidence etc, did you just wake up after a thousand years Sleeping beauty? You’re thinking money over the child in your profile picture? You are the lie ZG. A 110% Papua New Guinean FAKE. Hi Fiona and all my Papua New Guinean Brothers and Sisters! Blood is thicker than water. November 23 at 9:32pm
- Zenna Gaori sorry ted am not to sure what you’re talking about. i was only commenting to trangu man. this post is on Cr6+. as PR and awareness I connected to get some infor to Fiona in reply to her post.
November 24 at 10:56am
- Zenna Gaori you and trangu man switched to a very different topic. and yes, that’s my son on the profile and he has nothing to do with this. talk on the topic and do not side track. you both do not know how to debate professionally. speak your mind on the topic. November 24 at 11:01am
- Zenna Gaori if you both know fiona, ask her to send the email i sent regard chromite, hexavalent chromium Cr6+, and the project operation. in that way you dont argue out of the blue or rumors but facts November 24 at 11:04am
- Ted Soaremai This is professional debate Zenna. Tell me which part is not, outlined specifically please. And nah I don’t think I would waste time or Fiona’s and you shouldn’t too in sending that piece of crap around on the email as it was put together by them, using you again. I’d rather rely on Google, that shit’s poison. By the way, all this has everything to do with the child on your profile, he/she’s the future. But if you still don’t understand where all us PNG brothers and sisters trying to tell you, as you stated above, then you’re from another planet or simply, from that level —– of plain stupidity. Please take a sip and gulp of some Chromium Cr6+ and publish it in the newspapers for all to see please November 24 at 2:53pm
- PWP Ted, if ur interested,i can always send u the email.its MCC’s version for awareness purposes. Apparently the Chinese are shipping this chromite stuff soley for the LO’s benefit.MCC will make no profit whatsoever from the chromite but they figure the LO’s cud benefit from transporting it thus the whole issue.whats strange though is Ive never heard of chinese free handouts till nw. Why go to all the trouble if u wont be making any profit. Why ship chromite over if its valueless.i googled November 24 at 7:14pm
- Ted Soaremai Hahaha-Yes please do. I could use some insights into their lies. I wouldn’t mind getting it from you. Good team work FS. Email’s email@example.com 17 hours ago
- Ted Soaremai On another note, why don’t you copy and paste it on your wall and we’ll share it around 17 hours ago
- Zenna Gaori since yous have a both side information now, see the difference between chromite and hexavalent chromium? now keep your comments to yourselves and learn to review two sided infor before you speak your mind am out. 15 hours ago
- Ted Soaremai Oh no you’re not out Zenna, you are so on! 22 minutes ago
- Ted Soaremai By the way Zenna, here’s a link to Hexavalent Chromium on Google, please read! https://www.osha.gov/SLTC/hexavalentchromium/