Compensation process for rape victims at Porgera mine in Papua New Guinea ‘deeply flawed’, researchers say

PHOTO: The report's authors have investigated abuse allegations at the Porgera mine since 2006. (Supplied: Sarah Knuckey)

The report’s authors have investigated abuse allegations at the Porgera mine since 2006. (Supplied: Sarah Knuckey)

Pacific Beat | ABC News

US researchers say the process for compensating women who have been raped by security guards at Papua New Guinea’s Porgera gold mine is “deeply flawed and insulting”.

Experts from the Columbia and Harvard Law Schools in the United States conducted a three-year investigation into the system established by Barrick Gold, the owners of the Porgera mine, to directly remedy sexual assaults by its staff.

Sarah Knuckey, a co-author of the report, said most of the victims are unhappy with the reparation process put in place by the Canadian mining firm.

“Despite the efforts of the company, the ultimate result was deeply flawed,” Ms Knuckey told Pacific Beat.

“The process didn’t centre the victims sufficiently throughout the process.

“There were at least 120 women who have submitted claims to this remedy mechanism … most of them find that the process is deeply insulting to them.”

Allegations of brutality have long swirled around the Porgera mine in Enga Province, even before Barrick acquired it in 2006.

The allegations came to a head in 2011 when a Human Rights Watch report documented six alleged cases of gang rape by the mine’s security guards.

In response, Barrick set up what it called a “remedial framework” to handle claims made by the victims.

Most women were offered less than $8,300 each in compensation, the report said, as well as counselling and healthcare.

Ms Knuckey said 11 women who obtained US-based lawyers reportedly received packages that were 10 times higher than those who used Barrick’s process.

“The women who received the much smaller remedy feel that the reason they got such a lower remedy is because they didn’t have adequate legal representation through the process,” she said.

“The process just didn’t do enough to address the gross power imbalances between, on the one hand, a group of women who have not had the advantages of education, of lawyers. And on the other, one of the largest gold mining companies in the world.”

Ms Knuckey called on the Papua New Guinean government to review Barrick’s process and set in place guidelines for other similar remedy mechanisms.

“Barrick did an internal investigation, and in some cases evidence was referred to police,” she said.

“However, we haven’t been able to find evidence that through this investigation process the perpetrators were put through a court process and convicted.

“At the same time there also hasn’t been, so far as we can determine, any real investigation from the high levels of the government of PNG into whether the company itself bears any responsibility for the abuses in this case, which are very widespread.”

porgera woman mining

1 Comment

Filed under Papua New Guinea

One response to “Compensation process for rape victims at Porgera mine in Papua New Guinea ‘deeply flawed’, researchers say

  1. What an huge disaster! And will continue to be so for generations to come, even without this tragic mess Sadly, there will not be justice to anyone, as money will never serve to heal any of this. It adds to the insult.

    Rae Smart

    From: Papua New Guinea Mine Watch Reply-To: Papua New Guinea Mine Watch Date: Thursday, 10 December 2015 at 07:12 To: Rae Smart Subject: [New post] Compensation process for rape victims at Porgera mine in Papua New Guinea ‘deeply flawed’, researchers say

    WordPress.com ramunickel posted: ” Pacific Beat | ABC News US researchers say the process for compensating women who have been raped by security guards at Papua New Guinea’s Porgera gold mine is “deeply flawed and insulting”. Experts from the Columbia and Harvard Law Schools in the Uni”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s