Rio Tinto hands ABG and PNG poisoned chalice

Close up of a hand grenade on a white background

Has Rio handed the Bougainville and PNG governments a grenade with the pin out?

So, a company destroys a pristine ecosystem, helps to trigger a war, aids troops murdering civilians, and then abandons their investment without admitting liability or offering remedy – how would you describe this?

The Evening Standard went with the following headline ‘Rio Tinto gives golden gift of rights to Papua New Guinea mine worth $51bn’

Their strong journalistic grasp of the issues, is demonstrated in the article’s opening line: ‘the Bougainville mine is in Pangua, Papua New Guinea’ – you read that right, Pangua!

Less acceptable was Bougainville News who went with a similar headline: ‘Rio Tinto gives up Bougainville Copper stake worth $51 billion’.

Evidently this is the value of the remaining deposit in the Panguna region.

Of course no Auditors worth their salt would say Rio Tinto has given away $51 billion. Why? Because Rio Tinto does not have any legal right to extract the ore body, thats the first reason. Second, there is little chance any investor could reopen the mine, given strong local opposition, sovereign risk and other commercial challenges. 

Third, and perhaps most significantly, no one is able to coherently measure BCL’s liabilities. Were landowners and victims able to organise a successful legal action, damages would be approx $4bn, at a modest guess. This is far in excess of the actual value of Rio Tinto’s ‘golden’ gift, which is valued at $92.5m.

Rio Tinto may have just handed the PNG and Bougainville governments a grenade with the pin out. Not so golden after all.

2 Comments

Filed under Environmental impact, Financial returns, Human rights, Papua New Guinea

2 responses to “Rio Tinto hands ABG and PNG poisoned chalice

  1. The ‘golden gift’ that Rio Tinto is offering PNG and Bougainville for its Bougainville Copper Ltd (BCL) stake as at the 30 June 2016 was “worth over $40 million as of the close of trade yesterday” according to The Australian newspaper, not $92.5 million.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s